Sunday, September 22, 2013

Take research report with a pinch of salt - Case study: Suntec Reit

I used to own Suntec Reit, I would still like to own it if the price is right.

But I saw from a investment website that a certain research company has a price target of $2.01 using a DDM (dividend discount method).

I do not know the metrics used in this DDM calculation, but  I think the research is just too optimistic in its assessment. I think investors should take a conservative target price and not a highly aggressive target price.

First, lets do some reverse engineering.

Assume you think 6% yield for Suntec is cool (After all growth are factored in), given its "blue-chip" status. So you need 12 cent DPU, or 3 cents per quarter. So I would need distribution of about 67 million per quarter. Can Suntec achieve that?

Above is the upgrading plan, they expect NLA to increase by 25% and net net get a 33% increase in gross monthly rent. Lets give the retail revenue a 35% boost.

Let assume also 10% positive rental revision to its Suntec office, MBFC and other Jointly-controlled entities.

At such, the contribution from various units for DISTRIBUTION

SUNTEC retail = 18.75 million per Quarter

SUNTEC office = 19.5 million  per Quarter

Jointly-owned entities = 29 million per Quater

Parklane = 3  million

That is about 70 million, giving you a slightly above 6% yield, after 35% boost in retail contribution and 10% positive rental revision in office for all units.

If such liberal/optimistic assumptions do not pan out, you should be looking at 5-6% yield instead.

Do note, I did not take into account:

1) increase in finance costs with increase in interest rate

2) The increase in increase rate will lead to higher yielding bonds, and if the spread of about 4% is maintained, a 5% yield for a Reit instrument is hardly a sound and prudent proposition.

3) That the phase 4 AEI will complete only in 2015, so the full positive impact of retail reversion should come at 2015 earliest.

If you are happy with 5% yield, and is willing to hold it through thick and think, Suntec does look like a decent buy now, but if you are buying now hoping it will hit $2 in the next 12 months, I think the odds are not in your favor. (But you can be a lucky star and win against all odds)

Also, the research report talk about discount to NAV, I wish to highlight Suntec Cap rate is quite aggressive, and at $2, the discount will disappear.

1 comment:

  1. Do you need to increase your credit score?
    Do you intend to upgrade your school grade?
    Do you want to hack your cheating spouse Email, whatsapp, Facebook, instagram or any social network?
    Do you need any information concerning any database.
    Do you need to retrieve deleted files?
    Do you need to clear your criminal records or DMV?
    Do you want to remove any site or link from any blog?
    you should contact this hacker, he is reliable and good at the hack jobs..
    contact : cybergoldenhacker at gmail dot com